And I think he has a point. According to Saber’s wacky and way-above-my-head calculations, Francoeur generated soemthing like $13.78 mil a year for the Braves over the past three years. Actually, screw it – here is his summary for you to make sense of:
Is Francoeur worth $4 million to the Braves? The quick answer is yes, absolutely, and it’s not even close. Despite all the flaws in his game and his failure to meet misplaced expectations, he’s still a major-league baseball player. Even during his awful 2008 season, his marginal revenue product (MRP) contribution for his play in the field was approximately $12 million. This may seem like a lot, but all major-league quality baseball players are valuable assets. During the first six years of service, the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) limits player compensation, and that is why we can easily say that many players are worth more than they are being paid.
…
I have done some analysis of player salaries during arbitration years, but I haven’t gone that in depth. In my book, I report that position players tend to receive 77 percent less than their estimated marginal revenue product during their fourth through sixth years of service (estimated). Based on his previous three-year average of his MRP ($13.78 million), that puts his expected salary at $3.17 million. Based on his past season alone, his expected salary is $2.84 million. The Braves appear to have the better offer on the table.
So yes he is worth the $4 million but, at the same time, he isn’t. Either way the Braves will still make money with him, even if they have to pay $1.15 mil more than is standard. Of course Francoeur was one of the worst players in the Majors last year but he could, conceivably, bounce back to being average. If so, the $4 mil would be a steal, and I might even consider forgiving him for the shitshow that was his entire 08 season.
And as if Francoeur’s failure of a season wasn’t evident enough, Saber also adds this tidbit: “And according Plus/Minus, 2008 was a poor defensive season for Francoeur: he made 17 fewer plays than the average right fielder, ranking him 30th in the league.”
Ugh.